I hope that you simply spared a thought over the vacations for the poor Naylor brothers. In a premise tailored for a lesser Hallmark film, their time as teammates got here to an finish simply 4 days earlier than Christmas, when the Guardians traded Josh Naylor to the Diamondbacks in change for right-handed pitcher Slade Cecconi and a Aggressive Steadiness Spherical B draft decide. Simply 21 minutes after Jeff Passan broke the information that broke up the household, he additionally reported that veteran first baseman Carlos Santana had agreed to a one-year, $12-million deal to fill the outlet Naylor left within the Cleveland infield. He did not report on what, if something, would fill the outlet left in Bo Naylor’s coronary heart.
After 5 years away, Santana is coming house to Cleveland for the third time — one other stable premise for a Hallmark film. In actual fact, he nonetheless has a house in Cleveland. Or he did, anyway. He promote it a couple of weeks in the past and closed on a sale two days earlier than signing with the Guardians. One other enjoyable aspect notice to Santana’s signing: He very practically busted the We Tried Tracker. Ken Rosenthal listed seven different groups that had been in on Santana: “The Seattle Mariners, Santana’s staff in 2022, sought to reunite with him just about your entire offseason, and had been pushing for a decision. Santana mentioned each New York groups, Detroit and Arizona additionally had been within the combine, whereas San Diego and Texas had requested him to attend.” If you happen to’re preserving rating at house, that’s 4 groups that had been within the combine, two within the brand-new class of asking the participant to attend, after which the terribly thirsty Mariners. As you’ll have seen, Rosenthal is citing Santana himself because the supply for this data. If extra gamers spoke to reporters in regards to the curiosity they acquired, the tracker would look much more strong.
After working a mixed wRC+ of 94 from 2020 to 2023, Santana all of a sudden rediscovered his type with the Twins in 2024. In his age-38 season, Santana ran a 114 wRC+ with 23 house runs, and his 11 fielding runs earned him his first Gold Glove. He racked up 3.0 WAR, greater than he totaled in all however two of his 15 years within the huge leagues, and good for the fifth-most WAR amongst first basemen final season. His common contact high quality didn’t stray removed from his profession norms, and his vaunted batting eye remained about as robust as ever. The massive distinction is that 23.8% of his batted balls got here within the type of line drives or fly balls to the pull aspect. That’s his highest fee since 2014. Specializing in pull-side energy has been a main organizational focus for the Twins, a lot in order that earlier than the season, Trevor Larnach determined he’d gone too far in that course and wanted to develop a extra balanced strategy. Whether or not or not the Twins had been accountable for it, this strategy change actually labored for Santana, and the Guardians are hoping that he can hold each the bat and the glove going for yet another yr.
As for the Diamondbacks, they’re in for his or her first style of life with out a cornerstone on the chilly nook since 2010. Naylor might not be peak Paul Goldschmidt or Christian Walker, however he’s been a top-10 first baseman over the previous three years. As slugging first basemen who play larger than the numbers recommend, Naylor and Santana have so much in frequent. Each gamers are below six ft tall and each rely on the house run ball regardless of missing jaw-dropping exit velocities. Naylor hits the ball on the bottom extra usually and lacks Santana’s reward for staying throughout the strike zone, however he hits the ball more durable. Regardless of comparable common exit velocities and hard-hit charges, Naylor’s ninetieth percentile exit velocity was 106 mph, considerably greater than Santana’s 103.7-mph mark. In 2024, regardless of working a bottom-quartile groundball fee, Naylor put up the primary 30-homer season of his profession, to go together with a 118 wRC+. He’s now reached that mark or greater in every of the final three seasons. His 2.3 WAR ranked eleventh amongst first basemen in 2024, and his 7.0 WAR over the previous three seasons ranked eighth.
Santana’s deal is for precisely the identical quantity as MLB Commerce Rumors predicted that Naylor would get in his last yr of arbitration, and that’s what makes this such a Cleveland transfer. The Guardians are taking over extra danger because of Santana’s age and giving up Naylor’s greater upside, however basically, they swapped out two related gamers for an identical costs and wound up with a draft decide and an fascinating arm in Cecconi. Steamer tasks Naylor to place up 2.0 WAR subsequent season, in comparison with 1.2 for Santana. You possibly can perceive why, on the “5 and Dive” podcast, Jeffrey Paternostro known as the transfer, “so Guardians (derogatory).” It took an entire lot of labor for Cleveland to make its first base scenario a bit dicier in change for a pair longshots.
Cecconi introduced his arrival in Arizona with a bang in 2023, and I imply that very actually. He made 4 begins and three reduction appearances, working a 4.33 ERA and 4.37 FIP. Cecconi entered the 2024 season because the D-backs’ no. 5 general prospect and their system’s top-ranked pitcher, however he struggled mightily, working a 6.66 ERA and 5.02 FIP. He bounced between the minors and majors, and he was despatched to the bullpen in late July, however his 4.49 xERA and 4.70 xFIP — whereas nonetheless nothing to write down house about — had been a lot much less worrisome. Cecconi doesn’t rack up many whiffs or strikeouts, he doesn’t run a terrific groundball fee, and he doesn’t keep away from exhausting contact. However what he does have is stable management, a fastball that may attain 98 mph, three different pitches that grade out as above common in keeping with Pitching Bot, Stuff+, and StuffPro, and 0.155 years of service time.
The Rays had been rumored to be fascinated by him on the commerce deadline, and it’s totally potential that the Guardians flip him right into a serviceable pitcher. Though the fastball can attain 98, it averages nearer to 94 and bought rocked final season. Someway, the Diamondbacks let Cecconi throw it 55% of the time anyway. Possibly the Guardians will get him within the pitching lab and assist him work out a fastball that works. Possibly they’ll make him a full-time reliever to bump his velocity again as much as the highest of its vary. They’ll undoubtedly have him throw his heater much less usually. Then once more, perhaps they simply wished that draft decide.
